Proteomics Approaches - Oral Questions
Key Distinction
Remember this throughout:
- Bottom-up: Gel-based; proteins are separated BEFORE digestion
- Shotgun: Gel-free; entire mixture is digested BEFORE peptide separation
- Top-down: Gel-free; intact proteins analyzed WITHOUT digestion
1. The Three Approaches Overview
All three approaches share common phases but differ in timing of enzymatic digestion and state of proteins during separation.
| Approach | Strategy | Separation | Digestion |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bottom-up | Gel-based | Proteins separated FIRST (2D-PAGE) | After separation |
| Shotgun | Gel-free | Peptides separated (after digestion) | FIRST (whole mixture) |
| Top-down | Gel-free | Intact proteins (HPLC) | NO digestion |
Key distinctions:
- Bottom-up: Separate proteins → Digest → MS (PMF)
- Shotgun: Digest mixture → Separate peptides → MS/MS
- Top-down: Separate intact proteins → MS (intact mass + fragmentation)
Bottom-up is a gel-based strategy where proteins are separated before digestion.
Workflow:
- Extraction & Lysis: Release proteins from cells
- Sample Preparation: Denaturation, reduction, alkylation
- 2D-PAGE Separation:
- 1st dimension: IEF (by pI)
- 2nd dimension: SDS-PAGE (by MW)
- Staining & Visualization: Coomassie or Silver stain
- Spot Picking: Excise protein spots from gel
- In-gel Digestion: Trypsin digestion
- MS Analysis: MALDI-TOF for PMF
- Database Search: Match masses to identify protein
Identification method: Peptide Mass Fingerprinting (PMF) — based on fingerprint of a single protein.
Shotgun is a gel-free strategy where the entire protein mixture is digested first.
Why "Shotgun"?
- Like a shotgun blast — analyzes everything at once
- No pre-selection of proteins
- Relies on computational deconvolution
Workflow:
- Extract proteins from sample
- Digest ENTIRE mixture with trypsin (no gel separation)
- Separate peptides by multidimensional chromatography (e.g., MudPIT: SCX + RP-HPLC)
- Online LC-MS/MS: ESI coupled to tandem MS
- Database search: Match MS/MS spectra to sequences
Identification method: Based on thousands of overlapping peptide sequences — much higher coverage than PMF.
Key difference from Bottom-up:
- Bottom-up: Separate proteins first
- Shotgun: Separate peptides first
Top-down is a gel-free strategy where intact proteins are analyzed without enzymatic digestion.
Workflow:
- Fractionate proteins by HPLC (not gels)
- Introduce intact protein to MS (offline infusion or online LC-MS)
- Measure intact mass
- Fragment in gas phase (CID, ETD, ECD)
- Analyze fragments for sequence information
Main advantages:
- Complete sequence coverage: See the whole protein
- PTM preservation: All modifications remain intact
- Proteoform identification: Can distinguish different forms of same protein
- No digestion artifacts: See true mass of protein
Identification method: Based on intact mass + gas-phase fragmentation of the whole protein.
Note: Alkylation often skipped to measure true intact mass.
2. Sample Preparation & Extraction
Cell lysis disrupts cellular structure to release proteins. Three main approaches:
1. Chemical Lysis:
- Uses detergents and buffers
- Example: SDS disrupts hydrophobic interactions among membrane lipids
- Gentle, but may interfere with downstream analysis
2. Enzymatic Lysis:
- Uses specific enzymes to digest cell walls or extracellular matrix
- Examples: Lysozyme (bacteria), Zymolyase (yeast)
- Specific and gentle
3. Physical Lysis:
| Method | Mechanism |
|---|---|
| Mechanical (Blender/Polytron) | Rotating blades grind and disperse cells |
| Liquid Homogenization | Force through narrow space (Dounce, French Press) |
| Sonication | High-frequency sound waves shear cells |
| Freeze/Thaw | Ice crystal formation disrupts membranes |
| Manual (Mortar & Pestle) | Grinding frozen tissue (liquid nitrogen) |
After lysis: Centrifugation separates debris from soluble proteins (supernatant).
Both are pre-analytical complexity management steps to reduce sample complexity and compress dynamic range.
Depletion:
- Purpose: Remove high-abundance proteins that mask low-abundance ones
- When used: Essential for plasma/serum (albumin = ~60% of protein)
- Methods: Immunoaffinity columns, protein A/G
Enrichment:
- Purpose: Isolate specific sub-proteomes of interest
- Methods:
- Selective Dialysis: Membrane with tiny pores acts as sieve
- Microdialysis: Collect small molecules through diffusion
- Selective Precipitation: Salts/solvents isolate by solubility
- Immunoprecipitation: Antibodies isolate target protein
Approach-specific needs:
- Bottom-up: Complexity reduced physically on 2D gel
- Shotgun & Top-down: Complexity must be managed strictly during extraction to avoid overloading LC-MS
Final steps of sample preparation to ensure proteins remain denatured and accessible to trypsin.
Reduction:
- Reagent: DTT (dithiothreitol) or TCEP
- Purpose: Break disulfide bonds (S-S → SH + SH)
- Unfolds protein structure
Alkylation:
- Reagent: IAA (iodoacetamide) or IAM
- Purpose: Block free thiol groups (prevents disulfide reformation)
- Adds ~57 Da (carbamidomethyl) to each cysteine
Why important:
- Ensures complete denaturation
- Makes all sites accessible to trypsin
- Prevents protein refolding/aggregation
- Produces reproducible digestion
Approach differences:
- Bottom-up: Essential for proper IEF/SDS-PAGE
- Shotgun: Essential for making protein accessible to trypsin
- Top-down: Alkylation often skipped to measure true intact mass
Five main goals:
- Solubilize all protein classes reproducibly
- Including hydrophobic membrane proteins
- Use chaotropes (urea, thiourea) to disrupt hydrogen bonds
- Prevent protein aggregation
- Keep solubility high during IEF or digestion
- Use appropriate detergents
- Prevent chemical/enzymatic modifications
- Use protease inhibitors
- Work at low temperature
- Remove interfering molecules
- Digest or remove: nucleic acids, salts, lipids
- Enrich target proteins
- Reduce dynamic range
- Deplete high-abundance proteins
3. 2D-PAGE (Two-Dimensional Electrophoresis)
2D-PAGE separates proteins by TWO independent (orthogonal) properties for maximum resolution.
First Dimension: Isoelectric Focusing (IEF)
- Separates by isoelectric point (pI)
- Uses immobilized pH gradient (IPG) strip
- High voltage applied
- Positively charged proteins → cathode
- Negatively charged proteins → anode
- Each protein migrates until net charge = 0 (at its pI)
- Result: Proteins aligned horizontally by pI
Second Dimension: SDS-PAGE
- Separates by molecular weight (MW)
- IPG strip placed on top of polyacrylamide gel
- SDS denatures and gives uniform negative charge
- Smaller proteins migrate faster
- Result: Horizontal band resolved vertically
Final result: 2D map of spots — each spot = specific protein with unique pI and MW.
| Dimension | Property | Method | Direction |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1st | pI (charge) | IEF | Horizontal |
| 2nd | MW (size) | SDS-PAGE | Vertical |
The resolution of IEF depends on the pH range of the IPG strip:
| pH Range | Resolution | Use Case |
|---|---|---|
| Wide (3-10) | Lower resolution | Initial screening, overview |
| Narrow (e.g., 5-7) | Higher resolution | Detailed analysis of specific pI range |
Why?
- Wide range: Same physical strip length covers more pH units → proteins with similar pI hard to distinguish
- Narrow range: Same length covers fewer pH units → better separation of proteins with close pI values
Strategy:
- Start with wide range (pH 3-10) for overview
- Use narrow range strips to "zoom in" on regions of interest
Common staining methods:
| Method | Sensitivity | MS Compatible | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Coomassie Brilliant Blue | ~100 ng | Yes | Simple, reversible |
| Silver Staining | ~1 ng | Variable* | Most sensitive |
| SYPRO Ruby | ~1-10 ng | Yes | Fluorescent, linear range |
Silver staining is the most sensitive method, capable of detecting very low-abundance proteins.
*Silver staining compatibility with MS depends on the protocol — some fixatives can interfere.
After staining:
- Gel is digitized (scanner or camera)
- Image imported to software (e.g., Melanie)
- Spot detection and analysis performed
Master Gel: A synthetic reference map created from multiple gel replicates.
How it's created:
- Run multiple replicates of the same sample
- Use image alignment (matching) software
- Apply warping algorithms to correct geometric distortions
- Combine all spots detected across all gels
What it contains:
- Every spot detected across the entire experiment
- Characterizes a "typical profile"
- Assigns unique coordinates to each protein
How it's used:
- Reference for comparing samples (e.g., healthy vs. diseased)
- Enables consistent spot identification across experiments
- Facilitates quantitative comparison
Software features:
- Contrast adjustment
- Background subtraction
- 3D visualization
- Spot detection and splitting
Sample-Related Limitations:
- Hydrophobic proteins: Membrane proteins poorly soluble in IEF buffers
- Extreme pI: Very acidic (<3) or basic (>10) proteins hard to focus
- Extreme MW: Large (>200 kDa) don't enter gel; small (<10 kDa) run off
- Low-abundance proteins: Masked by high-abundance proteins
- Limited dynamic range: ~10⁴ vs. proteome range of 10⁶-10⁷
Technical Limitations:
- Poor reproducibility: Gel-to-gel variation requires triplicates
- Labor-intensive: Manual, time-consuming, hard to automate
- Low throughput: Cannot be easily scaled
- Co-migration: Similar pI/MW proteins in same spot
Practical Issues:
- Keratin contamination (especially manual spot picking)
- Streaking from degradation
- Background from staining
4. Enzymatic Digestion
Trypsin Specificity:
- Cleaves at the C-terminal side of Lysine (K) and Arginine (R)
- Exception: Does NOT cleave when followed by Proline (P)
Why it's the gold standard:
- Robustness: Stable and active across wide pH and temperature range
- High Specificity: Predictable cleavage sites enable accurate database searching
- Ideal Peptide Length: Generates peptides of 6-20 amino acids — optimal for MS detection
- Internal Calibration: Autolysis peaks (trypsin digesting itself) serve as mass standards
- Basic C-terminus: K and R promote ionization in positive mode
When to use alternatives:
- Proteins rich in K/R → use Glu-C (cleaves after Glu) for longer peptides
- Different sequence coverage needed → Chymotrypsin (cleaves after Phe, Tyr, Trp)
| Approach | When Digestion Occurs | What is Digested |
|---|---|---|
| Bottom-up | AFTER protein separation (2D-PAGE) | Single protein from excised spot |
| Shotgun | BEFORE separation | Entire protein mixture at once |
| Top-down | NO enzymatic digestion | N/A - intact proteins analyzed |
Bottom-up digestion:
- Called "in-gel digestion"
- Spot excised, destained, then digested
- Peptides extracted from gel
Shotgun digestion:
- Called "in-solution digestion"
- Whole lysate digested
- Produces complex peptide mixture
5. Peptide Cleanup & Separation
ZipTip: A 10 µL pipette tip packed with reverse-phase (RP) material.
Purpose:
- Desalt peptides (remove salts that interfere with ionization)
- Concentrate samples
- Remove detergents and buffers
How it works:
- Condition tip with solvent
- Bind peptides to RP material
- Wash away salts (they don't bind)
- Elute clean, concentrated peptides
When used:
- Bottom-up (gel-based): Preferred offline method for cleaning peptides from single gel spot
- Before MALDI-TOF analysis
- Improves MS sensitivity for low-abundance proteins
Shotgun & Top-down: Use online RP-HPLC instead (performs both desalting and high-resolution separation).
Reverse-Phase (RP) Chromatography: The dominant mode for peptide separation in proteomics.
Why "reverse-phase"?
- Normal-phase: Polar stationary phase, non-polar mobile phase
- Reverse-phase: Non-polar (hydrophobic) stationary phase, polar mobile phase
- It's the "reverse" of traditional chromatography
How it works:
- Stationary phase: C18 hydrocarbon chains (hydrophobic)
- Mobile phase: Water/acetonitrile gradient
- Peptides bind via hydrophobic interactions
- Increasing organic solvent elutes more hydrophobic peptides
Use in proteomics:
| Approach | RP-HPLC Use |
|---|---|
| Bottom-up | Offline (ZipTip) or online before MS |
| Shotgun | Online, coupled directly to ESI-MS/MS |
| Top-down | Online for intact protein separation |
6. MALDI-TOF Mass Spectrometry
MALDI = Matrix-Assisted Laser Desorption/Ionization
Step-by-step process:
- Sample Preparation:
- Analyte mixed with organic matrix (e.g., α-CHCA, DHB, sinapinic acid)
- Spotted on metal plate, solvent evaporates
- Analyte "caged" within matrix crystals
- Laser Irradiation:
- Plate placed in vacuum chamber
- UV laser (337 nm nitrogen or 355 nm Nd:YAG) pulses at sample
- Desorption:
- Matrix absorbs laser energy, rapidly heats up
- Controlled "explosion" carries intact analyte into gas phase
- Ionization:
- Protons transfer from matrix to analyte in the plume
- Most peptides pick up single proton → [M+H]⁺
Role of the matrix:
- Absorbs laser energy (protects analyte)
- Facilitates desorption
- Donates protons for ionization
- "Soft" ionization — even large proteins stay intact
TOF Principle:
- Ions accelerated through electric field → same kinetic energy
- KE = ½mv² → lighter ions travel faster
- Ions enter field-free drift tube
- Time to reach detector depends on m/z
- Small/light ions arrive first
Problems affecting accuracy:
- Spatial Distribution: Not all ions start at same distance from detector
- Initial Velocity Spread: Some ions have different starting speeds
Solutions:
- Delayed Extraction: Brief pause before acceleration allows ions to "reset" — more uniform start
- Reflectron: See next question
Problem: Ions of same m/z may have slightly different kinetic energies → peaks blur (poor resolution).
Reflectron ("Ion Mirror"):
- Electric field that reverses ions' direction
- Located at end of flight tube
How it improves resolution:
- Faster ions (higher KE) penetrate deeper into reflectron → longer path
- Slower ions (lower KE) turn back sooner → shorter path
- Result: Ions of same m/z arrive at detector at the same time
- Peaks become narrower → better resolution
Resolution formula: R = m/Δm (where Δm = FWHM of peak)
Three criteria for excellent data:
- Sensitivity:
- Ability to detect tiny amounts of sample
- Down to femtomole (10⁻¹⁵ mol) quantities
- Resolution:
- Ability to distinguish ions differing by at least 1 Da
- Calculated: R = m/Δm (FWHM)
- Depends on Reflectron and Delayed Extraction
- Accuracy (Calibration):
- How close measured mass is to true mass
- Requires regular calibration with known standards
- Expressed in ppm (parts per million)
MALDI produces almost exclusively SINGLY CHARGED ions.
Common ions:
- [M+H]⁺ — most common (protonated molecule)
- [M+Na]⁺ — sodium adduct
- [M+K]⁺ — potassium adduct
- [M-H]⁻ — negative mode
Advantage of singly charged:
- Simple, easy-to-read spectra
- Each peak = molecular mass + 1 (for proton)
- No charge deconvolution needed
Example: Peptide of 1032 Da appears at m/z = 1033 [M+H]⁺
7. ESI (Electrospray Ionization)
ESI = Electrospray Ionization — premier "soft" technique for liquid samples.
Step-by-step process:
- Spray Formation:
- Liquid sample pumped through fine capillary needle
- High voltage (2-5 kV) applied
- Forms Taylor Cone at needle tip
- Produces fine mist of charged droplets
- Desolvation:
- Warm, dry nitrogen gas injected
- Acts as "hairdryer" — evaporates solvent
- Nitrogen is inert — doesn't react with sample
- Rayleigh Limit & Coulomb Explosion:
- As solvent evaporates, droplet shrinks
- Charge density increases (same charge, smaller surface)
- Rayleigh limit: Point where charge repulsion > surface tension
- Coulomb explosion: Droplet bursts into smaller "progeny" droplets
- Cycle repeats until solvent gone
- Ion Release:
- Fully desolvated, multiply charged ions released
ESI produces MULTIPLY CHARGED ions — key characteristic!
Ion types:
- Positive mode: [M+nH]ⁿ⁺ (e.g., [M+2H]²⁺, [M+3H]³⁺)
- Negative mode: [M-nH]ⁿ⁻
- Creates a charge envelope (Gaussian distribution of charge states)
Why multiple charging is important:
- m/z = mass / charge
- More charges → lower m/z values
- Allows detection of very large proteins within typical mass analyzer range
Example:
- 50 kDa protein with +50 charges
- m/z = 50,000 / 50 = 1,000 (easily detectable)
Disadvantage: More complex spectra (multiple peaks per protein) — requires deconvolution.
Greatest advantage: Direct online coupling to HPLC.
Why this matters:
- ESI operates at atmospheric pressure with liquid samples
- HPLC separates complex mixture over time
- ESI continuously ionizes components as they elute
- Ions sent directly into mass analyzer
Result: LC-ESI-MS/MS — the workhorse of shotgun proteomics.
Additional ESI advantages:
- Very high sensitivity (attomole range — 1000× better than MALDI)
- Soft ionization (large proteins intact)
- Multiple charging enables large protein detection
Trade-offs:
- More complex instrumentation
- Slower analysis (chromatography time)
- Sensitive to salts/contaminants
ESI Limitations:
- Sensitive to contaminants:
- Salts disrupt Taylor Cone formation
- Cause ion suppression
- Requires rigorous sample purification
- Complex spectra:
- Multiple charge states per molecule
- Requires computational deconvolution
- Slower throughput:
- LC separation takes time
- Not as fast as MALDI for simple samples
- More complex instrumentation:
- Requires LC system
- More maintenance
8. MALDI vs ESI Comparison
| Feature | MALDI | ESI |
|---|---|---|
| Sample state | Solid (co-crystallized) | Liquid (solution) |
| Ions produced | Singly charged | Multiply charged |
| Sensitivity | Femtomole (10⁻¹⁵) | Attomole (10⁻¹⁸) — 1000× better |
| Contaminant tolerance | High (robust) | Low (sensitive to salts) |
| LC coupling | Offline | Online (direct) |
| Spectra | Simple | Complex (multiple charges) |
| Throughput | High (~10⁴ samples/day) | Lower (LC time) |
| Best for | PMF, rapid fingerprinting | Shotgun proteomics, deep mapping |
Summary:
- MALDI: Favored for speed, simplicity, and tolerance to contaminants
- ESI: Gold standard for high-sensitivity proteomics and complex LC-MS/MS analyses
9. Peptide Mass Fingerprinting (PMF)
PMF: Protein identification technique based on the mass spectrum of proteolytic peptides.
Principle: Each protein produces a unique "fingerprint" of peptide masses when digested with a specific enzyme.
Complete workflow:
- Spot Recovery: Excise protein spot from 2D gel (robotic or manual)
- Destaining: Remove Coomassie or silver stain
- Reduction/Alkylation: Break disulfide bonds, block cysteines
- In-gel Digestion: Trypsin digestion overnight
- Peptide Extraction: Recover peptides from gel pieces
- Cleanup: ZipTip desalting
- MALDI-TOF Analysis: Acquire mass spectrum
- Database Search:
- Compare experimental masses to theoretical "digital digests"
- Databases: UniProt, Swiss-Prot
- Software assigns Mascot score (statistical probability)
Identification criteria:
- Significant number of peptides must match
- Typically need 4-6 matching peptides
- ~40% sequence coverage considered good
Limitation: Only works if protein is in database.
10. Quick Review Questions
Test yourself with these rapid-fire questions:
Bottom-up separates ❓ before digestion Proteins (via 2D-PAGE)
Shotgun separates ❓ after digestion Peptides (via LC)
Top-down analyzes proteins ❓ digestion WITHOUT any digestion (intact)
DTT is used for ❓ Reduction (breaking disulfide bonds)
IAA is used for ❓ Alkylation (blocking cysteine thiols)
The 1st dimension of 2D-PAGE separates by ❓ pI (isoelectric point) via IEF
The 2nd dimension of 2D-PAGE separates by ❓ MW (molecular weight) via SDS-PAGE
MALDI produces ❓ charged ions Singly charged [M+H]⁺
ESI produces ❓ charged ions Multiply charged [M+nH]ⁿ⁺
The Rayleigh limit is reached when ❓ Charge repulsion > surface tension → Coulomb explosion
The Reflectron improves ❓ Resolution (compensates for kinetic energy spread)
ZipTip is used for ❓ Desalting and concentrating peptides
Why avoid SDS in IEF? ❓ It binds proteins and imparts negative charge, interfering with pI-based separation
Use ❓ detergent instead of SDS for IEF CHAPS (zwitterionic)
Silver staining is more sensitive than Coomassie by approximately ❓ 100× (1 ng vs 100 ng detection limit)
ESI can be coupled ❓ online or offline to HPLC? Online (direct coupling)
MALDI is typically ❓ online or offline? Offline
ESI sensitivity is in the ❓ range Attomole (10⁻¹⁸)